The "Virgin" Birth
DECEMBER 21ST, 2008 — FOURTH SUNDAY OF ADVENT
Dear Friends,
Weather permitting, this Sunday we will have what promises to be a lively and informative discussion
based a Chapter from John Shelby Spong's book: Born of a Woman: A Bishop Rethinks the Virgin Birth
and the Treatment of Women ;by a Male-Dominated Church. The discussion will be facilitated by Jim
Fitzgerald whose M. Div. thesis was based on research of St. Augustine's view on sexuality and its
resultant impact on our church's theology of sexuality (or lack thereof).
The particular chapter of Spong's book that we are reading and discussing, The Cost of the Virgin
Birth, Spong contemplates the reality that "ideas have consequences". Taking that to heart, Spong
explores the development of Christianity's understanding of Mary as conceiving Jesus without
"knowing man" as the story is relayed in 2 of our 4 gospels, and its subsequent evolution of Mary into
"a male created female figure who embodies the kind of woman dominant males think is ideal-docile,
obedient, powerless." (Spong, 221) This image has provided a "safe" feminine connection for male
celibates who "could safely adore the virgin with passionate prayers and romantic meditations"
without compromising their celibate souls. However, this 'privilege' has contributed to the cost
of women bear in every conceivable circumstance, with the trickle down effect being that women who
seek to self-actualize and to claim their power in the world (and church), are seen as aberrations,
'sinners', evil. What if Mary hadn't been a "virgin"? What if she and Joseph had a normal healthy
loving sexual relationship? Surely the God who created us as sexual beings could take on flesh
in keeping with this Loving Creator's design. If that had been so, how might our church look on
married love, and on sexuality itself? My sense is we would have a more highly developed and,
indeed, reverenced theology of sexuality.
Sunday we will read Luke's story of the angel announcing to Mary "the virgin" that she is to bear a
child, Jesus. Despite the wording we are given of her response "be it done to me according to your
will" and whether spoken as "virgin" or not, Mary's "yes" was not the commitment of a weak,
submissive woman. It was an assent born of strength and integrity, and the opening of her heart
and her body, in a way that only woman can, to enable God's Word to become flesh in our world.
If you are looking for a "spiritual home" to support as you say "yes" to God 's coming to birth anew
in your life, we invite you to join us at the Spirit of Life. As a community, we try wholeheartedly
to "be Christ" to one another, to tend to the needs of one another and to those in need in our world.
Together, we celebrate our belief that we are being transformed by God's grace as we gather together
in prayer. We warmly invite you to come and gather with us at our Table and join in our experience
of the 'kin-dom' of God. We are an inclusive, open, affirming and interactive community, deeply
committed to being a people of 'justice and joy'.
Loving blessings to you as you in these final days of Advent,